Devil’s Advocate: Man Utd defeat a harsh lesson for Milan that proves one concerning thing

By Oliver Fisher -

Losing is hard to take as a football fan, especially when the stakes are at their highest. Some defeats evoke more positivity than others, while some fan bases react differently based on circumstance.

Based on social media, it would be fair to say that the general consensus about Milan’s Europa League last 16 exit against Manchester United was the proverbial ‘close but no cigar’; that is to say the team played well but could not finish the job.

Now, there are some very important factors that certainly did not help the team heading into the two legs and in particular the second leg. The injury bug has been rife for a while now and has made it difficult for head coach Stefano Pioli to field a consistent line-up from one game to the next, and that makes it hard to plan and execute against the top opponents.

Without sounding too morbid, that is the story of Milan’s 2021 so far. What was a season so full of promise and the potential for silverware via the Scudetto, Europa League and/or Coppa Italia has slipped into something different, due to uninspiring campaigns in the latter two and a real fight on our hands to seal a top four spot. Selection problems have slowly eroded at the momentum and sapped the enthusiasm.

That context makes it quite hard to have the following view, but at the same time football is all about lessons, and a very harsh one was dished out last night. The game was virtually a carbon copy of the first leg, as United were awful for 80 mins or so in each game and Milan could not put them away.

In the first half of each leg there was excellent game management from Milan but they did not show even an ounce of composure in the opposition third and against a team of such quality, that is going to hurt. What is incredibly frustrating is that the Premier League side struck so soon after the interval again in the return leg just as they had the first, implying there were no lessons learned on that front and it left Milan chasing the game with a depleted attack and tired legs.

The reaction on social media was very much along the lines of how the team ‘battled so hard’ against ‘a better team’, that they should hold their heads high, with mentions of differences in club revenue and the fact United are the tournament favourites.

While that is all true and relevant to varying degrees, United were there for the taking and the bottom line is that the team did not seize their opportunity. If Milan want to go anywhere and be taken seriously, they cannot play the underdog card constantly. The team has to win big games, and the theme so far this year is that they have fallen at each major hurdle.

Defeats to Juventus, Atalanta, Inter and Napoli are bad enough – with a damaging defeat to Spezia also thrown in for good measure – but the United tie was the latest example that this team have not yet taken that next step in terms of mentality.

What is that next step? It’s to win the big games consistently. There’s even a step before that, and that’s to make sure that if you can’t win against those teams around you, you make sure that you don’t lose the ‘six pointer’ games. Milan’s record this year shows they are not there yet.

Milan dominated their opponents from England for 75% of the tie. Is that a positive? Perhaps, but it also makes it even worse that they didn’t go through. Injuries or not (and Solskjaer had some to battle too), Milan had the chances to kill them and didn’t.

This comes back to the point that nobody remembers the “oh but we could have won” – they remember the wins, the winners, the trophies. This is a club steeped rich in history because of the silverware that adorns the club’s headquarters, the lack of spare space on the honours board, and not because of the ‘almost but not quite’ defeats.

Milan are currently in the midst of a project which by all means is a very exciting one. There are some talented young players to build around for the future without a doubt, and the hope has to remain that a top four spot is secured and that squad can be built on again in order to move on to the next step, which is a return to the Champions League.

To expect too much too soon would be wrong, and this isn’t meant to come across as a message that Milan should dominate Manchester United and beat them comfortably – they are still a great team that has had a lot of investment. Not many sides can bring a €100m midfielder off the bench to win the game.

However, it does serve as further proof – given the nature of the performances, the lack of goals and the recent stretch of form – that this team has not yet taken that decisive step. A work in progress, with the labour hopefully soon to bear more fruit.


Tags AC Milan Milan Manchester United

8 Comments

  1. victor says:

    We did have more possession, but how many real scoring chances did we have ?

    1. rivera says:

      How much more money in wages does Hakan want for his display in latest game?
      The same for Romangioli maybe dead wood should be replaced?
      The will we see the big and great signing Maldini & Massara to make ACM great and not be beaten by Inter, Juve, Atalanta and SPEZIA! Lets not forget MAN UTD!

  2. Ibn O. says:

    I totally disagree with this post.

    What to do with a frontline spearheaded by Castillejo? What mentality or positivity or message does it evoke to the opponents or even to our team itself?

    Please we should write for writing sake, Milan and Pioli have been dealt a tough hand by how the January transfer has let down our attacking department.

    If there was quality in the attack, then your mentality criticism would have been the right thing.

    1. Oliver Fisher says:

      So you don’t really totally disagree with it at all then, given I mentioned how injuries have dealt us a tough hand and made everything much more difficult. Even with those injuries, we dominated large stretches and didn’t show the composure that we should have – that’s on us, and on our players. We found a way to win before without key players, did it all throughout the first round, now we have two wins in eight, cannot score at home and are losing big big games. That’s a mental block. No other explanation – we have to learn.

  3. Hamid says:

    First post match article that is spot on. Milan in 2021 have forgotten how to score goals, injuries or not. There were some key players back last night, Hakan, Theo and Ibra, and not be able to score or even create any scoring chances bar one for the entire second halves in either leg, is disappointing. ManU also had significant injuries across the two legs, but simply put, they took their chances and won.

    Milan have come a long way from last season, but haven’t yet won anything, and recent matches show they still have a long way to go. They’d better gather themselves quickly now for the most decisive phase, as Napoli, Atalanta, Roma and even Lazio are circling in.

    1. Calais says:

      No Hamid, I have to say you are wrong. It is not that Man U “took their chances and won”. I don’t like this defeatist attitude from Milan, we need stronger personalities here. Kessie took his chance in leg 1 and we should have moved on to the next round. It wasn’t even a questionable handball, it just purely wasn’t one. Yes with injuries our attack is lacking and I agree with that but we still deserved to move on and got robbed, that’s a fact.

    2. Zoro Caloro says:

      Disagreed. They didn’t win because they “took their chances”, they won due to ref help.

  4. Zoro Caloro says:

    The “One Concerning Thing” is that Man U is still getting ref help in the age if VAR.. we got very unfairly robbed of progression by a fake handball on Kessie’s goal. We outplayed them both legs even with a B squad and received the Man U ref help treatment. Fun.

Comments are closed

Serie A Standings

Live football scores . Current table, fixtures & results.